Critical Analysis On Social Security Code, Significance of Gig and Platform Workers in India

The introduction of the social security code in India is an important step towards reformation of workplaces. Social security is commonly viewed as a sort of monetary assistance provided by the government to persons who are either inadequately employed or can’t be employed. In India, the term “social security” has a completely different connotation.

Our social security system in India is made up of various labour laws that our state and central governments have enacted over several years. These govern salaries and benefits for workers, as well as safe working conditions and regulate labour and industrial relations.

The Code on Social Security, 2020, amalgamates eight previously existing labour laws of centre. These are the Employees’ Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions

Act, 1952; Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972; Employees’ Compensation Act, 1923; Maternity Benefit Act, 1961; Employees’ State Insurance Act, 1948; Workers Cess Act, 1996; Cine Workers Welfare Fund Act, 1981; Building and Other Construction and Unorganised Workers’ Social Security Act,2008.

This Code isn’t just a collection of previous laws consolidated into one. It has expanded the coverage, made benefits available to all workers in the organised and unorganised sectors, incorporated notions of giving maximum benefits with minimal governance, and demonstrated consistency in approach.

The Code aims to bring uniformity to the provision of social security benefits to employees, which were previously divided into different acts with varying applicability and coverage. The Code also attempts to give social security to a large group of workers by recognising and covering workers in the unorganised sector. Under this code, draft rules have been published by the Government.

The law also broadens the scope to include fixed-term contract workers, who will now be entitled for gratuities, whereas previously only permanent employees were covered. As per the Code, an employee is entitled to gratuity if they are terminated from their job after a continual service tenure of at least five years,

which is the same as earlier. The events that would lead to gratuity are as follows: retirement, resignation, death or permanent disability as a result of an accident or illness, or termination of a contract under a fixed-term employment contract, or on the occurrence of any event notified by the Centre. In the eventuality of an employee’s death, the gratuity would be payable to the employee’s nominee or legal heir. As a result of the inclusion of the term “expiration of fixed-term employment”, now fixed-term contract employees too will be entitled for gratuity.

Under the new laws, these workers will be covered by social security benefits such as income services and health insurance. Several new terms have been developed, such as gig workers, platform workers, and fixed-term employees, which previously were not acknowledged by any labour laws. Gig workers and platform workers, who are part of the unorganised workforce, were not legally recognized by the Government for many years. Since these workers were not paid on a salary basis, they were deprived of many benefits such as Health Insurance, Provident Fund, etc. The new regulations provide gig workers a shared identity.

Definition of “Gig Worker”In India, the phrase “gig worker” is a relatively recent notion. Generally, a gig worker is someone who works hourly or does part-time jobs in various fields, ranging from catering events to developing software, and many more. The job is generally temporary and performed within a set timeframe under an unusual employment arrangement. The term “gig worker” is defined in the Code as, “a person who performs work or participates in a work arrangement and earns from such activities outside of traditional employer-employee relationships’. The legal identification of gig workers was urgently needed because the concept covers a large group of contract employees. Even a part-time professor can be covered in the gig economy. Contingent employees, freelancers, and independent contractors are just a few examples of prevalent names. The gig economy finds its origin and is mostly popular among youths in Western countries. This model enables students to start working at a young age and get expertise in their chosen fields. The perks involved with such employment would inspire individuals in India to pursue these jobs and avail benefits that arise out of it.

Definition of “Platform Worker” In general, a platform worker is someone who works for an enterprise that offers specific services to clients, customers, individuals or organisations through an online platform.

Uber, Ola, Zomato, etc. are some of its examples. According to the Code, a platform worker is, “a person engaged in or undertaking platform work”. In order to have a fuller insight, the definition of platform worker must be read in conjunction with the definition of platform work, which specifies what platform work is. It is defined as, “a work arrangement outside of a traditional employer-employee relationship in which organisations or individuals use an online platform to access other organisations or individuals to solve specific problems or to provide specific services or any such other activities which may be notified by the Central Government, in exchange for payment.”

The Central Government has proposed to generalise benefits such as health and maternity benefits, as well as life and disability insurance. The state government is responsible for providing benefits to workers such as provident fund, skill upgradation, and accommodation. Nirmala Sitharaman, the Finance Minister of the nation, has also stated that all sorts of workers would now be subject to minimum wage regulations and that the Employees State Insurance Corporation, or ESIC, will apply to the government. The Centre also has no information about how many gig workers at present are now employed in India; however, some

independent estimates put the figure at above 130 million. To reap the benefits of these planned incentives, the government has planned to create an online platform for all qualified unorganised workers in the country by June 2021. It’s mandatory for all the gig and platform workers to register on this portal. In order to be eligible, the worker must be over the age of 16 and under the age of 60. Also, they have worked for at least 90 days in the past 12 years. The worker would be required to submit a self-declaration, either online or offline, as well as additional documents, including the Aadhar Card.

The Central Government could also choose five members for the unorganised sector to the National Social Security Board, which will frame policies and regulations for gig and platform workers. Furthermore, the Code requires aggregators, or employers in the case of gig workers, to donate a set proportion of their revenue to a social security fund for the unorganised sector’s welfare.

India is now seeing a booming phenomenon where a lot of start ups are coming up and their business model rests on such kind of an arrangement where they are engaging these people on an independent contract basis meaning thereby, that there is no employer employee relationship with them and so they are not suppose to comply with all the labour laws that exist in the country because all of them focus on an employee so one concern is that if a recognition is given to these gig workers then even the business model of these organisations might collapse because they are engaging these people in thousands of numbers.

These workers who have constantly been asking for certain minimum benefits for themselves. A couple of years back certain organisations of these workers came forward and filed a PIL in Delhi High Court asking for setting up of a committee that can examine whether they can be treated as an employee, whether they can get the benefits under labour laws but there was no headway on that front. So, it’s a very tricky balance to meet. So, the government has tried to do that by not saying that these are employees on one hand and on the other hand giving them at least social security benefits meaning thereby providing life benefit, health benefit, benefit in relation to accidents.

So, the government plans to formulate a scheme under the code on social security which will provide at least these benefits to gig workers, platform workers. There has been an attempt to balance both the interests.

ISSUES WITH THE SOCIAL SECURITY CODE

The Social Security Code, 2020 [SS Code] consolidates nine laws relating to social security, including the Unorganised Sector Social Security Act, 2008 [USS Act] – one of the few pieces of legislation which was applicable to unorganised workers. The SS Code has been viewed by many as a missed opportunity to strengthen the social security net for workers. Trade unions and labour activists have been consistently demanding that social security be universalised and a rights-based approach adopted.

The National Commission for Enterprises in the Unorganised Sector [NCEUS] in its policy papers has many time and again recommended a universal national minimum social security scheme for unorganised workers as a matter of entitlement. Such a social security scheme, it stated, must cover life, health, and disability, as well as maternity and old age security for unorganised workers in the agricultural and the non-agricultural sectors. The NCEUS had also suggested that two comprehensive laws be introduced for the unorganised agricultural and non-agricultural workers to ensure minimum conditions of work and social security. The NCEUS’s recommendations, however, did not find a place in the USS Act, a piece of legislation which has been critiqued for being a paper-tiger, or the SS Code.

The Social Security Code, for the first time, defines ‘gig workers’ and ‘platform workers’. The intent behind this is to bring them within the scope of social security nets. A gig worker is defined as “a person who performs work or participates in a work arrangement and earns from such activities outside traditional employer-employee relationships”. Platform work is defined as “a work arrangement outside of a traditional employer-employee relationship in which organisations or individuals solve specific problems or provide specific services or any such other activities which may be notified by the Central Government, in exchange for payment” and a platform worker as one who engages in platform work. The SS Code also defines an unorganised sector worker as one who works in the unorganised sector and is not covered by the provisions of the Industrial Relations Act, 1947. Consequently, both gig workers and platform workers are also covered by the definition of unorganised sector worker.

Including gig workers and platform workers within the scope of a social security legislation is a welcome move since they had an ambiguous status in law, allowing for ease of exploitation as they are treated as freelance workers. India has also witnessed considerable debate concerning whether tech gig work platforms (such as Uber, Zomato, Swiggy, and so on) qualify as employers or are mere intermediaries. The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom, in its judgement Uber BV & Ors. vs. Aslam & Ors. last year, held that platforms such as Uber qualify as employers, thus making drivers eligible for employee benefits and protections.

While this case is an important precedent, it is yet to be seen what impact it will have on the regulatory landscape for gig and platform workers in India. While the SS Code takes a step in the right direction, the definitions of gig worker, platform worker and unorganised sector worker are overlapping and confusing. As the Code envisions different social security schemes for each of these categories of workers, there is a lack of clarity about what scheme will apply to whom, potentially leading to challenges at the stage of implementation.

Another issue is that the SS Code largely replicates the failed USS Act in its approach to social security. Similar to the USS Act, the SS Code adopts a welfare-based approach towards social security and places an obligation on the union and state governments to ‘frame and notify, from time to time, suitable welfare schemes’. The Code provides for the setting up of helplines or facilitation centers to assist unorganised sector and gig/platform workers. However, it leaves this to the discretion of the government. While it empowers the union government to frame social security schemes for gig and platform workers, here again, such obligation is not mandatory. The language of the SS Code, just like the USS Act, continues to treat workers as beneficiaries of government benevolence and does not provide any timeframe for the introduction of schemes. The IFT petition, which seeks a reframing of social security as a matter of right, is critical in this context.

The SS Code also does away with progressive provisions of the USS Act, such as workers facilitation centres. Under the USS Act, the government was mandated to set up workers facilitation centers which would register and issue portable social security cards to unorganised sector workers and provide them various forms of assistance. A similar provision does not find mention in the Code.

Further, the funding of social security schemes for unorganised and gig/platform workers is dependent on the coordination of the union government and state governments, and in some cases, aggregators. This raises concerns about financing of these schemes, given the Centre and State may keep tossing the ball in each other’s court and not take responsibility. Aggregators may not be happy about having to make financial contributions which eat into their profits and may challenge such a statutory mandate.

Finally, the shoddy implementation of the earlier USS Act by both the union and the state governments suggests the likelihood of this experience being replicated in case of the SS Code. The adoption of a failed welfare-based approach towards social security, the absence of binding obligations on the government to extend protection and assistance to unorganised sector and gig/platform workers, and the lack of progressive provisions that found mention in the USS Act demonstrate the missing political commitment on the part of the government to bring vulnerable workers within the net of social security.

As we move towards a largely informalised gig-based economy, it is critical our labour laws evolve to adequately respond to it, while staying true to their original objective of protecting workers interests and redistributive justice. The SS Code, which is being paraded as a progressive move for gig/platform workers, is a mere lip service to social security, and we should be wary of such window dressing.

[crp]

Latest Indian news

Popular Stories

Latest Video