NEW DELHI – Widespread outrage has erupted following the arrest of renowned academic Professor Ali Khan Mahmudabad, who teaches at the prestigious Ashoka University, after his remarks on the recent Operation Sindoor press conference.
Mahmudabad was arrested by Haryana Police on Sunday morning following complaints by Haryana State Women’s Commission Chairperson Renu Bhatia and Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) youth wing leader Yogesh Jatheri. The complaints were registered at the Rai police station in Sonipat.
The FIR based on Bhatia’s complaint invoked sections 152 (acts endangering sovereignty, unity, and integrity of India), 353 (statements conducing to public mischief), and 79 (word, gesture, or act intended to insult the modesty of a woman). A second FIR filed by Jatheri included sections 196 (promoting enmity between groups), 197 (statements prejudicial to national integration), 152, and 299 (deliberate acts intended to outrage religious feelings).
DCP (Crime) Narendra Singh stated, “There were two complaints — one from Renu Bhatia concerning a Facebook post and the professor’s disregard for the commission’s summons, and another from a sarpanch alleging the professor made objectionable statements to him.”
The complaints followed Mahmudabad’s social media post questioning the optics of having Colonel Sophia Qureshi lead a press briefing on Operation Sindoor — a military operation against Pakistan.
Delhi University professor and rights activist Apoorvanand, who had opposed the summons issued to Mahmudabad, condemned the arrest, calling it discriminatory.
“There may be democracy in India for others, but not for Muslims. They have no democratic rights except to praise the government,” he told The Hindustan Gazette. “Ali Khan said nothing that could even be called criticism of the government, yet he was arrested. This highlights the increasing risks for Muslims who think and speak freely.”
Referring to past cases involving Muslim intellectuals and activists, Apoorvanand said, “Whether it is Umar Khalid, Sharjeel Imam, or Gulfisha Fatima — whenever Muslims use their minds and voices, their freedoms are threatened.”
He emphasized Mahmudabad’s academic stature, saying, “He is a responsible scholar and his post praised the Indian Army. His only ‘crime’ was to assert that Muslims have the right to live with dignity. It’s outrageous to claim he insulted Wing Commander Vyomika Singh. Anyone reading his post would find it difficult to see where such an allegation comes from.”
In the Facebook post in question, Mahmudabad criticized warmongering and highlighted what he saw as hypocrisy among right-wing commentators who praised Colonel Qureshi while remaining silent on the persecution of ordinary Muslims in India.
“I’m glad to see Colonel Sophia Qureshi being applauded, but the same voices must also call for justice for victims of lynchings and bulldozing of homes. Optics matter, but they must translate to reality — otherwise, it’s hypocrisy,” he wrote. “When a Muslim politician said ‘Pakistan Murdabad’ and was trolled by Pakistanis, Indian right-wingers defended him, calling him ‘our mullah’. It’s funny, but it reveals how deeply communalism has penetrated our politics.”
The Women’s Commission’s notice, issued on May 14, objected to Mahmudabad’s use of terms like “genocide,” “hypocrisy,” and “dehumanisation,” accusing him of misrepresenting facts and questioning the legitimacy of women’s roles in the military.
In his response, Mahmudabad rejected the accusations, writing: “My post applauded the armed forces for choosing Colonel Qureshi and Wing Commander Singh to represent Operation Sindoor. I emphasized the vision of India’s founders — of unity in diversity. I even praised right-wing supporters of Qureshi and asked that they extend the same attitude to ordinary Indian Muslims. My comments were aimed at protecting both citizens and soldiers.”
The arrest has drawn criticism from academics, activists, and political leaders across the spectrum.
Congress leader Pawan Khera tweeted, “A historian and academic is jailed not for inciting violence but for advocating against it. His crime? Speaking truth to power and calling out the BJP’s communal narrative.”
TMC MP Mahua Moitra also condemned the arrest, stating, “Ali Khan @Mahmudabad is one of India’s most eminent scholars with global recognition. If he is arrested on Mickey Mouse charges & jailed, then it is only because of his name.”

